herojjco's pick · Updated October 2026
Temptations MixUps Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats
Loading photo

Temptations MixUps Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats, Catnip Fever, 16 oz may suit cat owners who want a treat that feels more interesting than a plain biscuit and who are looking for a single tub they can keep around for training, bribery, or occasional rewards. The crunchy and soft mix is the main reason to consider this style of treat, since some cats prefer a little texture contrast and some owners prefer a treat that can be broken up or portioned in small amounts. A larger 16 oz container can also make sense if treats are used regularly and you do not want to replace a small pouch all the time.
The main thing to check is whether the ingredient list and flavor profile fit your cat's needs. With any treat, it is worth confirming the calorie count per piece, the salt level, and whether anything in the formula conflicts with your cat's usual diet. If your cat is on a restricted plan, has food sensitivities, or tends to gulp treats too quickly, the label matters more than the marketing. The name suggests a catnip-forward treat, but that is still something to verify against your cat's actual response, since not every cat reacts the same way to catnip.
This kind of product is usually best thought of as a reward treat rather than a meal supplement. That means the useful comparison is not only taste, but also how easy it is to control portions and how well the texture works for your cat's teeth and chewing habits. Some cats like a treat they can crunch; others are better off with something softer. The mixed texture is a plus if you are unsure which camp your cat falls into, but it may also be the part that makes this less ideal for a very particular eater.
There is no need to assume too much from the listing alone. What matters is how the treat fits your cat's routine, your storage needs, and your comfort with the ingredients. If you are comparing options, look at the calorie density, ingredient transparency, package size, and whether the treat is something you would feel good using often. That is the practical way to judge a cat treat like this one.
In the end, this may be a good fit for someone who wants a recognizable treat format, a larger tub, and a blend of crunchy and soft pieces in one product. It is worth considering if your cat enjoys novelty and you want a simple reward option, but the label is the place to slow down and confirm fit before you decide.
Some Amazon links are affiliate links. herojjco may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
See current price